CCGs strain to hear voice of patients

9 January 2013

CCGs understand the need to engage with patients but questions remain about their ability to translate good intentions into effective plans and to hold their nerve when unpopular decisions need taking.

These are among the findings of a new report based on interviews with 18 people from six CCGs including the clinical lead (usually the chair), accountable officer and lay board member.

Commissioned by the Department of Health for the NHS Commissioning Board, the study* found a high level of awareness and enthusiasm for the principle but underlying anxieties about PPE in practice.

The report’s authors deliberately talked to CCGs in the second and third waves of authorisation to get a picture of the average. They found most of the sample able to produce examples of engagement initiatives targeted to particular conditions (for example dementia and HIV) or around particular services (for example urgent care). They also found CCGs starting to have “productive discussions” about investment priorities and the need for service change.

These examples should not be mistaken for what the report calls an “embedded engagement culture”.  Acknowledging that CCGs are still barely formed, the report expresses concern about the “few specific examples of PPE in the authorisation process” and the lack of involvement of lay members.  Only one of the CCGs had involved a lay member in the authorisation process.

Despite signs of engagement activity, there is less evidence of shared understanding and “a lack of understanding about what it might mean to be ‘patient-focused’ or ‘patient-centred’”.

The report also raises questions about whether CCGs are engaging people at the right time. Engagement tends to be concentrated on the middle phases of the commissioning cycle (planning and service design), but should start earlier with “needs and aspirations”, the authors suggest. Similarly, patients and the public could be involved in the later procurement and monitoring phases of commissioning, allowing them to influence the choice of provider and the quality of the service.   

The report found evidence that some CCGs see potential for conflict in their roles as patient champions and effective commissioners. “Many…aim to be responsive ‘listening organisations’. This does not always sit comfortably with the need to make tough commissioning (and decommissioning) decisions.”

The report’s co-author Andrew Craig of Moore Adamson Craig Partnership, said: “These CCG leaders know that embedding engagement in everything they do is essential if they are to make commissioning decisions and service changes with broad user and carer understanding and community support. 

“They are hungry for metrics to measure the impact of their engagement efforts.  With the right support and encouragement they should quickly become local organisations that listen and engage well.”

Interviewees acknowledged concerns that patient participation groups (PPGs) were not representative of the wider population and related concerns about their ability to scale up communication to large numbers of people.  The authors concede that these groups may be the “primary building blocks” for engagement, but point out that CCGs have yet to tackle the problem of how to use PPGs as part of bigger engagement structures.

Article Type
Leadership and engagement

Latest News

Dementia diagnosis rates: December 2016

24 January 2017

The national clinical director for dementia, Professor Alistair Burns has written to CCGs with the national dementia diagnosis rate as part of the national ambition to diagnose two-thirds of dementia cases in the population. The letter urges commissioners to work with general practices, particularly those with low diagnosis rates, who are invited to seek support from NHS England’s Intensive Support team.

Read More

Health matters: combating high blood pressure

24 January 2017

Public Health England has published guidance to help providers and commissioners to reduce blood pressure through improved prevention, detection and management.

Read More

Technical guidance to support national wheelchair data collection

24 January 2017

The submission window for quarter 3 data for the national wheelchair data collection is open from now until 25 January 2017. NHS England has prepared a technical guidance document to help CCGs to submit good quality data.

Read More

Bringing new care models within reach of general practice

24 January 2017

The primary care home is rapidly gaining favour as the acceptable face of new care models. This version of primary care at scale, backed by the National Association of Primary Care, and now being piloted at 15 test sites is proving popular with GPs because it represents less radical change for general practice – or to use a phrase borrowed from Simon Stevens “goes with the grain”. Two articles from PCC, including one from Professor David Colin Thomé, who first described the original primary care home concept, set out the issues.

Read More

The future is provision, enabled and not led by commissioners - A way forward for community based care

24 January 2017

The Primary Care Home (PCH) is a concept I first described some ten years ago. It is a population budgeted community based provider organisation able to provide an alternative to current NHS hospital centricity. A home not only for general medical practitioners and their teams but for all primary care independent contractors (pharmacists, dentists, optometrists) and their staff, community health services and social care professionals. And potentially a home for many currently working in hospitals in particular those clinicians who have a responsibility for long term conditions care, for rehabilitation and reablement and for the hospital specialists who offer “office based” procedures. The population would be of GP registered patients’ lists aggregated to whatever size is locally appropriate.

Read More