Getting GPs on board remains a big issue for accountable care organisations

6 October 2017

In August NHS England published documents setting out current thinking on the relationship between GPs, practices and various forms of accountable care organisations (ACOs). The papers included a new version of the ACO contract that will evolve further over the coming months.

A key issue is how GPs can be encouraged to participate in integrated delivery models.

The NHS England documents set out three levels of possible integration of GP practices into the new MCP/ACO provider organisation: virtual, partial and full.

The move towards the ACO model is being shaped by the aspiration to put in place long term outcomes based contracts that incentivise providers to invest in population health improvement.

Ensuring there are appropriate methods for GP involvement is part of a range of work that NHS England and the Department of Health are still finalising to underpin the future arrangements, in partnership with a range of CCGs who are already moving through procurements using the draft ACO contract.

Even temporarily moving away from their current GMS/PMS arrangements can be a leap for practices, even though they can reactivate these contracts. This explains why in the early procurements the partially integrated model is likely to be the most popular form of ACO. Under this model all GMS/PMS contracts remain as they are. GPs remain independent but practices enter an integration agreement with an ACO provider. The agreement should address issues of integration around estates, the workforce and referral patterns so that everyone is working to the same model.

The event underlined the importance of setting out the specific actions each party is taking in the integration agreement. Otherwise, speakers warned, you may risk ending up with a slightly embellished community services contract. They also emphasised the importance of primary care to the successful delivery of the model.

Several areas are also trialling the virtual model where integration is encouraged through an alliance agreement. Robert McGough, a partner at law firm Hill Dickinson, suggested that with some providers only signing up to quite “loose” arrangements it will take some time to achieve significant integration and there will be a spectrum of models.

“The virtual or partially integrated ACO will not deliver core GP contract services so you will have to figure out how you integrate practices and change how they work. Enhanced services may well be within the scope of the wider ACO contract so that may be a way of incentivising GP involvement.”

McGough said “I’m not aware of anyone using the fully integrated model currently. Most are looking at the virtual model to test it out and perhaps use this as a staging post. GP collaboration is a fundamental issue but GMS and PMS contracts can be like rocks in the sand for integration. GPs only four to five years away from retirement may be questioning why they would take such a risk.

“It will theoretically be possible for GPs to reactivate their GMS or PMS contract if the ACO or MCP doesn’t work out. This option is proposed to be available at regular intervals throughout the ACO contract’s duration. However, the lack of certainty around the list in the context of the novelty of some of these arrangements explains why many practices are not initially opting for the fully or even partially integrated models.”

McGough also suggested that commissioners can still have influence the new commissioning rules, saying: “There is an appetite at NHS England and the Department of Health for listening to the case for regulatory change based around the lessons coming from the vanguards but that is a narrow window.”

[related articles:]

NHS England’s proposed contractual approaches for accountable care models

Commissioners must drive but leave providers to steer new care models

Accountable care organisations need support to get GPs’ pay right

Support updates Our news

Latest News

Guidance on data off-shoring and cloud computing for health and social care

22 January 2018

National guidance has been published, setting clear expectations for health and care organisations who want to use cloud services or data off-shoring to store patient information.

The guidance will ensure that organisations know how to use these solutions safely and securely. It has been timed to appear as NHS organisations face tighter restrictions on the processing and transfer of personal data when the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) takes effect in May.

The document also highlights the benefits for organisations choosing to use cloud facilities.

Read More

NHS continuing healthcare funding failing the people who need it, say MPs

22 January 2018

NHS continuing healthcare funding intended to help some of the most vulnerable people in society is not reaching people who need it. That’s one of the conclusions of the latest parliamentary report which describes a complex process beset with delays and poor-quality assessments.

Read More

Revised never events policy and framework

22 January 2018

NHS Improvement has published a revised policy and framework for avoiding never events. The document clarifies who may be involved in identifying, investigating or managing never events. CCGs should note the removal of financial sanctions from the NHS standard contract in relation to never events. The updated 2017-19 NHS standard contract is to be used from 1 February 2018. Providers are asked to ensure their local policies and procedures align with the revised national policy framework.

Read More

Making sense of accountable care

22 January 2018

Accountable care is the latest health policy buzz phrase. But where did it come from and what does it really mean? The King’s Fund is promising to explain all with a short briefing that promises accountable care in a nutshell and a long version that goes into more depth.

Read More

Consultation on research in the NHS

22 January 2018

On 30 November 2017 NHS England launched a consultation to support research in the NHS. The consultation sets out proposals to manage excess treatment costs better and to improve commercial clinical research set-up and reporting. We are inviting stakeholders, including NHS commissioners, to share views on these proposals. The consultation ends on 1 February 2018. For further information, contact

Read More