Getting GPs on board remains a big issue for accountable care organisations

6 October 2017

In August NHS England published documents setting out current thinking on the relationship between GPs, practices and various forms of accountable care organisations (ACOs). The papers included a new version of the ACO contract that will evolve further over the coming months.

A key issue is how GPs can be encouraged to participate in integrated delivery models.

The NHS England documents set out three levels of possible integration of GP practices into the new MCP/ACO provider organisation: virtual, partial and full.

The move towards the ACO model is being shaped by the aspiration to put in place long term outcomes based contracts that incentivise providers to invest in population health improvement.

Ensuring there are appropriate methods for GP involvement is part of a range of work that NHS England and the Department of Health are still finalising to underpin the future arrangements, in partnership with a range of CCGs who are already moving through procurements using the draft ACO contract.

Even temporarily moving away from their current GMS/PMS arrangements can be a leap for practices, even though they can reactivate these contracts. This explains why in the early procurements the partially integrated model is likely to be the most popular form of ACO. Under this model all GMS/PMS contracts remain as they are. GPs remain independent but practices enter an integration agreement with an ACO provider. The agreement should address issues of integration around estates, the workforce and referral patterns so that everyone is working to the same model.

The event underlined the importance of setting out the specific actions each party is taking in the integration agreement. Otherwise, speakers warned, you may risk ending up with a slightly embellished community services contract. They also emphasised the importance of primary care to the successful delivery of the model.

Several areas are also trialling the virtual model where integration is encouraged through an alliance agreement. Robert McGough, a partner at law firm Hill Dickinson, suggested that with some providers only signing up to quite “loose” arrangements it will take some time to achieve significant integration and there will be a spectrum of models.

“The virtual or partially integrated ACO will not deliver core GP contract services so you will have to figure out how you integrate practices and change how they work. Enhanced services may well be within the scope of the wider ACO contract so that may be a way of incentivising GP involvement.”

McGough said “I’m not aware of anyone using the fully integrated model currently. Most are looking at the virtual model to test it out and perhaps use this as a staging post. GP collaboration is a fundamental issue but GMS and PMS contracts can be like rocks in the sand for integration. GPs only four to five years away from retirement may be questioning why they would take such a risk.

“It will theoretically be possible for GPs to reactivate their GMS or PMS contract if the ACO or MCP doesn’t work out. This option is proposed to be available at regular intervals throughout the ACO contract’s duration. However, the lack of certainty around the list in the context of the novelty of some of these arrangements explains why many practices are not initially opting for the fully or even partially integrated models.”

McGough also suggested that commissioners can still have influence the new commissioning rules, saying: “There is an appetite at NHS England and the Department of Health for listening to the case for regulatory change based around the lessons coming from the vanguards but that is a narrow window.”

[related articles:]

NHS England’s proposed contractual approaches for accountable care models

Commissioners must drive but leave providers to steer new care models

Accountable care organisations need support to get GPs’ pay right

Support updates Our news

Latest News

NHS diabetes prevention programme fact sheet

20 April 2018

This fact sheet gives more detail about the NHS diabetes prevention programme and how it supports patients identified at high risk of developing Type 2 diabetes.

Read More

Paying for IAPT case studies

20 April 2018

NHS England has published case studies based on the experience of five organisations (three CCGs and two providers) on developing and implementing a new payment approach for improving access to psychological therapies services, which link a component of payment to quality and outcome-measures. The case studies may help commissioners develop their own outcomes-based payment approach. As local pricing Rule 8 of the 17/19 National Tariff requires organisations to adopt an outcome-based payment approach by April 2018, these case studies could be of particular value at this time.

Read More

Advance care planning for people with dementia

20 April 2018

NHS England’s dementia team has just published a guide to advance care planning for people with dementia in all care settings. The dementia challenge 2020 maintains that “by 2020 we would wish to see… All people with a diagnosis of dementia being given the opportunity for advance care planning”. NHS England developed the guide with input from dementia experts, carers, health and social care professionals.

Read More

NHS Employers GMS negotiator roles available

20 April 2018

Applications are now open for General Medical Services (GMS) negotiator roles within the NHS Employers primary care contracting team. The GMS negotiations are undertaken by a team of specialist negotiators appointed by NHS Employers and NHS England and supported by a primary care contracting team consisting of technical and subject experts. To find out more and apply, visit the NHS Employers website.

Read More

Developing new models of care in the PACS vanguards: a new national approach to large-scale change?

20 April 2018

A report was commissioned by NHS England as part of a package of support provided to primary and acute care system (PACS) vanguard sites by the King’s Fund. The PACS model is an attempt to bring about closer working between GPs, hospitals, community health professionals, social care and others.

As the national new care models programme comes to a close, those who have led the development of the PACS model were invited to reflect on the process of being part of the programme, and of trying to bring about complex change in local systems. This report is not an evaluation of the PACS model or of the new care models programme, but it offers a unique set of first-hand perspectives into the experience of those leading a major programme at the national level and those living it at the local level.

Read More